Thanksgiving Myths

Thanks for sharing this!

Here in Carpenter Country, the short one was thinking about Thanksgiving, and how great it must have been for the Pilgrims to sit down with their Indian friends to share a wonderful harvest.

And what a menu–turkey, dressing, mashed potatoes, sweet potatoes, corn bread, gravy, cranberries, pumpkin pie.

Hmmm–sounds almost too good to be true.

And a quick check shows it is. Seems most of the short one’s grade school turkey day learning was no more than a myth.

So, what’s the truth? As usual there are conflicting stories.

According to historians the first feast was just that, a first feast, and not the beginning of a tradition. Also the celebration could have occurred anywhere from late September to early November. The menu was made up of venison and wild fowl, which meant the bird may or may not have been a wild turkey. Fruit and dried corn probably rounded out the meal. There was no dancing, playing games or singing.

Indian scholars interpret the day differently. In their telling ducks, geese and venison, most likely brought by Massasoit, the Indian sachem, were the items on the menu. Only Massasoit was asked to join the feast, and he, not the Pilgrims, invited the other members of his tribe. Any good cheer was caused by a lot of “home brew.”

Whichever version you choose to believe, and there are many others, the general consensus was and is–the Pilgrims wore no black clothes, pointed hats or shoes with buckles.

Well, that certainly punctures the short one’s balloon of childhood memories. However, she’ll get happy again as soon as she sits down to a holiday dinner with all the trimmings.

But before she does, she wants to wish everyone a wonderful Thanksgiving.

And that’s no myth!

You might also like these posts

Essay — Birds in the bath series — Blue Jay A feathered bit of sky landed in one of Carpenter Country's bird baths this week. Ms. Blue Jay thoroughly enjoyed splashing in the water. Image source: HL Carpenter   We enjoyed learning about how the inner structure of blue jay feathers creates a trick of light. Image source: HL Carpenter   ...
Essay — Busy reading Image source: HL Carpenter   "Come pick up two books," the voice on the phone said. Bright and early the next day, we traveled to the library to collect our windfall and instead of two books found five best sellers waiting for our reading pleasure. Yep, FIVE! WOOHOO! We may not accomplish much work here in...
Essay — Garden Pests Carpenter Country's weekly dose-of-nature essays tend to reflect the beauty we see. That preference doesn't mean we're oblivious to other aspects of the natural world surrounding us, including those who recently turned the lush stand of four o'clocks into stalky skeletons of their former selves.   Image source: ...
Essay – Clearing the clutter Some days the path ahead is cluttered with debris.   Image source: HL Carpenter   And some days the debris is bagged and ready for disposal.   Image source: HL Carpenter   Are you clearing the clutter from your life?   ***** ***** ABOUT THE AUTHOR ***** HL Carpenter...

We write. Visit us in Carpenter Country, a magical place that, like our stories, is unreal but not untrue.

Posted in Essays Tagged with: ,